Category Archives: Articles and Reviews

First Review of “This Mobius Strip of Ifs” by Shirley Roe, AllBooks Review

July 2011

Before I begin, I will state that I am a huge fan of Mathias Freese. His novel, The i Tetralogy, sits in a place of honor on my bookshelf as one of the books I shall never forget. This Mobius Strip of Ifs is a collection of essays written by the author over a long period of time and finally brought together in a fascinating work of literary genius. I sit and read the essays and sometimes I find myself in a place of deep soul searching and discovery, other times I am simply entertained, but never disappointed.

Each essay has something truly unique and heart wrenching. The following quote is only a small part of the therapist’s relationship with the client. However, as you read, it permeates your core as very sound advice for any relationship.

Therapist as Artist:  “Some comments about the relationship with the client. As you fade, the client becomes clearer. Think of yourself as the Cheshire cat in Alice in Wonderland.

Use yourself as an instrument. Use images, analogies, metaphors; be nimble on your feet. Use words gracefully, cunningly, but never deceitfully. Be multiplex. Think and be in large, not small, measures.  Give and ye shall receive twice-fold.

As you feel, sense and intuit the client, feel his impact upon yourself. Think of meteors raining down upon the moonscape and the lunar quakes that ensue and seismic waves that are issued deep down to its core. Engage and motivate.”  Truly thought provoking!

To quote Jane Freese, who puts it beautifully in the introduction, “A Möbius strip is essentially a ribbon with a twist. A mathematical model, it is used as a metaphor by physicists to describe why we, living within four dimensions, are unable to perceive other dimensions outside of the single boundary of time.” The collection covers religion, the Holocaust, publishing, writing, movies, actors, therapy and life in general, from the author’s point of view. Readers will be entertained, challenged, and yes, shocked by some of the writings. Another winner from Matt Freese that I have thoroughly enjoyed from start to finish and I am sure will return to often in the future.

 

Highly Recommended by Reviewer:  Shirley Roe, Allbooks Review.

A Remarkable Review by Mayra Calvani

Mayra Calvani did an incisive interview with me some months back.  She also reviewed Down to a Sunless Sea quite favorably. Her site is darkphantom.com and she now freelances at Today.com. A novelist and reviewer, she is the recent author of a book on reviewing on blogs. I asked if she might review The i Tetralogy, cautioning her as I often do with reviewers about the graphic and very disturbing aspects of the book, telling her to read the autobiographical essay at the end so as to determine my writerly aims and intentions.

In private correspondence she recently shared how disturbing the book was for her, how she found it difficult to sleep and how the book became so much for her at times that she had to go away from it. Nevertheless, she felt the book had to be read. I shared with her that the book had cost me psychologically as well, that a book like this one comes but once to a writer in his or her lifetime; that I doubted I would ever near its intensity ever again or come upon such insights as I did into human behavior. In fact the book intimidates me! It is hard to work on the next book having such a shadow cast upon my efforts.

Calvani’s review is at http://booktalkcorner.today.com/2009/01/22/not-just-another-book-about-the-holocaust/. If I typed this incorrectly just go to her site. I want to quote some of her words because she is the best reader of this book so far:

“I have chosen to review this book in the first person instead of my usual third, if only because it shook me so deeply. Freese shows humanity as it is, in its own raw and naked reality. He does it with bluntness, yes, but with incredible insight. His sentences flow like the blood that gushed from ther victims’ veins during this terrible event — relentless and ruthless. The protagonists reveal themeselves to the core, from the deepest corners of their minds to the bottomless misery of their hearts. I found myself taking breaks between readings. I had to. Immersing myself in this story was killing me a little every time. This is without a doubt the most terrifying book I have ever read, and not because of its callous bluntness, but because it made me realize what human beings can be capable of. ‘To ask why there is evil in this world is to ask who we are.,’ writes Freese (343). I think this sums up the essence of the book. It also brings up the question: is the bystander who watches and lets it happen less guilty than the murderer?”

A very gutsy woman — and reader. The rest of the review contains this kind of intensity.

When I had completed the first novella, i, I shared it with a social worker who had survived Auschwitz. I did not know that. One evening she called me and said: “What part of the camp were you in?” I broke down . I then went on to write three more novellas. Calvani’s review has impacted me in a different way as well. I know I have done my task and I have been truthful to my purposes. No amount of fame, money or accolades can match or equal the value I have received from touching another person who senses my sensibility and who reads my work as if every page counts.

On a slightly tangential note, often reviewers — I should say bloggers — complain that my book of short stories is too dim, dark or desperate; that if they read such a book they want an “Anne Frank” moment, as I call it. That false, surreal belief that for every dark moment there has to be one of light. The shallowness is appalling, expressing the inability to see the species and individual people as they are, not as one might want them to be. Anne Frank has been ripped-off, for she wrote her book not in a camp but in a hidden room. Some do not consider her book as part of Holocaust literature. Her thoughts are turned to “sweeten” the Holocaust because human beings — and that means you and you — cannot cope with their own hearts of darkness. And believe me, you have one. I have seen it as a living person and I have experienced it as a psychotherapist. Many of us live lives of quiet desperation, playing ducks-and-drakes with life, skimming the lake waters.

Kudos to Mayra Calvani for not fleeing from the light.

Breenibooks.com Review of Stricken

If you go to breenibooks.com a review of Stricken by me is available for 10 December. I have decided not to do reviewing as it takes away from my own writing, my own life, if it be said. Time is very precious to me. However, if something really good is proffered and it is no more than 250 pages I will review it. In any case the aforesaid review gives you a sample of how I go about reviewing. (Contact me if you have a book of interest.) The book was about loss in all its varieties and if anything, by the time we all come to die, we have become quasi-experts on death and dying. 1960, 1999 are indelible milestones in my own experience with loss of the most grotesque kind, one by cancer, the other through a horrific car crash. Of course, closure is for those Americans who suck on the nipple of MYSpace, YouTube, and Twitter. Closure, my ass. Loss is an open-ended ache until you die yourself.

For the past year I have been involved in costly litigation, trying to sell a house in this moribund market, unintended construction costs to repair an electrical problem of some magnitude in the house, the usual harassing shit of living life, the grotesqueries of neighbors who are trailer trash and all the rest while I try to use this mind of mine to find a clear, well-lighted place to attain some respite, some space to respire freely so that I can manage all this looming, impending and nagging crud!  I work hard on falling back on those values and memories that fortify me for adversity and often it works but it is draining and often tiresome to be so defended in order to walk ahead. I compare my worries and anxieties, often really difficult ones, to the image of Rochelle lying dead on a gurney. It is this flashback remembrance that holds me steady as I face human dreck, folly and the inanimate world.

Within this passive-aggressive personality is embedded a high-strung, anxious person who uses control to defend against the pressures of everyday life. Control doesn’t work, for it is a temporary measure, like a dam against Katrina. (Re: Ordinary People. . . “Control is a bitch.”) Inevitability destroys control. The secondary defense, I imagine-think-believe, is to fight back, more in self-defense than out opf character-driven intention. The inner, quaking fear which I have never experienced, but a fear nevertheless, is that I may shatter, but shatter I do not during impossible moments of stress, such as losing one’s mother, losing one’s wife. I do not will this resiliency; it simply exudes, like a rich sweat after a workout. I am stronger than I think, and I am weaker than I think, might say it all.

Like lint in a dryer’s filter, we gather debris as we course through life. Divorces, deaths, major mistakes and minor catastrophes, so by the time we are my age or nearing our journey’s end, we can turn back and see this human comet trail of absolute junk. And then it is over. As I ponder this aimless wool-gathering, I wonder if i can see what it is as opposed to find meaning in it. I’d rather see than understand. When I have seen I have grown or deconditioned myself. At times meaning is a slugfest while seeing is to spin a Venetian glass. Adieu.

ANNOUNCEMENT: POD REVIEWER FOR BREENI BOOKS

Sabrina Williams has reviewed both of my books at Breenibooks, http://breenibooks.blogspot.com/.  Her reviews ( see them both at her site)  went far beyond what a writer might expect, especially her review of The i Tetralogy. So I responded very recently to her notice about POD reviewers and her open and diverse thinking about publishing on demand in general. Only today I had a blogger in her profile say that she did not accept self-published books. I feel that is narrow-minded, to say the least. Some bloggers, many? few? who knows, are inexpert in writing and in how to write a review, but for some odd reason here on the web they express literary airs. The aforementioned blogger also requested hardback review copies. Sense the latent meaning to that demand.

One thing led to another and Sabrina Williams has announced that a group of POP reviewers (see her site and announcements) are available for authors to submit their works. Some of the sites and individuals on that list are reputable if not knowledgeable about the field. As a POD author I am now one of her reviewers.

I urge you to read the list of reviewers, seek out their sites, review their efforts to decide if there is compatibility. In this light, read my 2 July blog in which I announced that I would review books, POD or not POD. Over the years I reviewed books for psychology journals as well as ezines. In that announcement I gave the “flavors” I like to review in literature. I also set out parameters. On this site are two queries for your perusaI. I use them to have my books reviewed or looked at by publishers. I prefer that the author send me a query with all the background data about the book as well as a statement of what the book is about. The query itself is a measure of an author’s ability to get to the point. It tells me if I am dealing with someone, quite frankly, who is trying to be serious about his or her craft. It is not a hazing process. It says much about the author. On the basis of that, I will request to see your book or kindly state it is not for me.

I will not attack you as a person — I have had that unpleasant experience by a demented blogger. I feel your ideas and how you express them or not is fair game. I am not afraid of dissenting with you or criticizing your ideas, or relishing how well you craft your work, or how insightful you are. You as a person will not be handled roughly, mark my words, but your content, whatever, is subject to my thought processes. That is why a query helps me assess what kind of book is being presented to me. Before you send off your book to a pod reviewer scan and study his or her site, your market for your work.

Finally, I do not enter “challenges” (see the previous blog) or hurry through a book so that I can impress other bloggers with how intelligent I am. You will have a professional writer reading your book who happens to have a blog. I will also bring to it my years as an English teacher and psychotherapist. I am serious but not somber about life. Send me your best effort and if you think it is fluff pass me by…Don’t worry, I only sound tough.

Kind Regards,

Matt

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...